Reformation vs Carhartt WIP: which button-up wins?
Both land in the mid tier — the Reformation Reformation Will Oversized Shirt at $98, the Carhartt WIP Carhartt WIP Madison Shirt at $98. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Reformation | Carhartt WIP | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $98 | $98 |
| Material | Cotton poplin, breathable linen, and fluid TENCEL or silk-blend fabrics chosen for drape and a soft hand. | Cotton oxford and poplin, sturdy twill, and brushed flannel chosen for durability and a clean, casual hand. |
| Fit | Relaxed and oversized with dropped shoulders and a longer hem; meant to be worn loose, tucked, or knotted. | Regular-to-relaxed fit with a clean shoulder and easy body; cut to layer over a tee with a slightly boxy line. |
| Quality | Clean finishing and considered details, though the delicate linens and silk blends require gentler handling and wrinkle easily by nature. | Solid seams, sturdy buttons, and durable cottons reflect the workwear lineage with a tidier streetwear finish. Built for regular wear. |
| Best for | Easy, feminine layering and warm-weather dressing, worn open over a tank or tucked into trousers and skirts. | Workwear-streetwear and clean-casual looks, worn open or layered over a tee with denim and chinos. |
| Care | Follow garment labels closely; many styles are best hand washed or dry cleaned, and linen is meant to be worn relaxed and lightly creased. | Machine wash cold and tumble dry low; the twill and flannel soften with washing while keeping structure. |
Which should you buy?
They sit in the same tier and are priced identically, so it comes down to what you want out of a button-up. Lean Reformation for easy, feminine layering and warm-weather dressing, worn open over a tank or tucked into trousers and skirts; pick Carhartt WIP for workwear-streetwear and clean-casual looks, worn open or layered over a tee with denim and chinos.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.