Loro Piana vs Target — Goodfellow & Co.: is the pricier short worth it?
The Target — Goodfellow & Co. Linden Flat-Front Chino Short runs $22; the Loro Piana Cotton-Linen Bermuda Short is $695 — about 31.6× the price ($673 more). Here's the side-by-side, and what that gap actually buys.
| Target — Goodfellow & Co. | Loro Piana | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $22 | $695 |
| Material | Lightweight cotton poplin with a touch of added spandex for give; thin-ish and prone to wrinkling. | Italian-milled cotton-linen twill, roughly 50/50, mid-light weight with a soft slubbed hand and natural drape. |
| Fit | Flat-front straight-ish cut with a mid rise, available in 7"/9"/11" inseams; runs true-ish but sizing is inconsistent between colors and batches. | Relaxed tailored Bermuda with a mid-to-high rise and a roughly 9–10 inch inseam hitting just above the knee; cut clean and easy, not slim. |
| Quality | Basic budget construction — fine out of the box, but colors fade and the cloth softens and can pill at the seat after a season. | Exceptional cloth and clean Italian finishing, but the construction and hardware are standard luxury — the fabric is the achievement, durability is the trade. |
| Best for | Everyday warm-weather wear, yard work, and anyone who wants a cheap stock of multiple colors without caring if they last. | Warm-weather quiet-luxury dressing for someone who values fiber and drape over logos and won't mind — or will embrace — the linen wrinkle. |
| Care | Cold wash and tumble low or hang to slow fading and keep the thin cloth from wearing out; expect some wrinkling. | Dry clean or gentle cold hand-wash and hang to dry; expect linen creasing and treat it as a delicate warm-weather piece, not a workhorse. |
What you’re paying more for
At about $695 this is a fabric-and-pedigree purchase, not a construction one — the cotton-linen cloth is legitimately among the best you can buy, but the stitching, hardware, and durability are ordinary luxury, not extraordinary. If the feel and drape of elite Italian linen matter to you, it delivers; if you want the money in seams and longevity, this is mostly mill markup and a quiet logo tax. Honest buyers should know it wrinkles and wears like any fine linen, just more expensively.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.